ONE OF THE MOST well-established findings of psychological research is what’s known as the fundamental attribution error. What that means, in a nutshell, is this. When we try to explain why somebody else behaved in a certain way—especially when the behavior is negative—we tend to downplay or ignore situational factors and attack the person’s character instead.
I think here of the woman who answered a call and began talking on her phone just as the theater went dark and the movie began. The other people in the theater (including myself, unfortunately) immediately assumed she must be either rude or clueless. Someone sitting behind me yelled at her to shut up. As she got up to leave, she shot back that her husband had just gone into the hospital, and she had been waiting for a phone call from the doctor. True, a movie theater wasn’t the wisest choice of a place to wait for such a call. But once people understood the situation, there were no more complaints.
The other side of the fundamental attribution error is how we explain our own bad behavior. Suddenly, situational factors prevail, not character. If someone else misbehaves, it’s because they’re a bad person. If we misbehave, however, it’s because the situation forced us to, and anyone else would have done the same. That’s an exaggeration, of course; it’s not as if we’re incapable of recognizing the flaws in our own character. But we’re much more likely to give ourselves the benefit of the doubt than we are to give it to others, especially to those who have offended us in some way.
But think about it. If this flawed way of thinking is as common as the research suggests, then we’re not the only ones failing to give the benefit of the doubt to other people. They aren’t giving us that courtesy either. If they’ve taken offense at something we’ve said or done—perhaps unknowingly!—then they’ve already passed judgment on our character. Wouldn’t we want them to be more generous of spirit toward us?
Probably. But if that’s the kind of world we want, it’s up to us to make the first move, to act toward other people the way we would want them to act toward us.
In that vein, listen again to the words of Jesus:
But to you who are listening I say: Love your enemies, do good to those who hate you, bless those who curse you, pray for those who mistreat you. If someone slaps you on one cheek, turn to them the other also. If someone takes your coat, do not withhold your shirt from them. Give to everyone who asks you, and if anyone takes what belongs to you, do not demand it back. Do to others as you would have them do to you. (Luke 6:27-31, NIV)
Even if you’d never heard that whole text before, you might still have recognized the last line, the so-called “Golden Rule.” This would not have been a completely new idea to Jesus’ hearers. As I suggested in the previous post, an ethic of reciprocal obligation was already part of the culture; if people wanted to be treated in a certain way, they had to act in a certain way. And Rabbi Hillel, the founder of one of the two main schools of rabbinic Judaism in Jesus’ day, was famous for having taught, “What is hateful to you, do not do to someone else.”
But while these are similar to the Golden Rule, what Jesus teaches is different. The idea of reciprocity, for example, may help people mind their manners, but the motivation is essentially selfish: Do this so others will treat you well. And the teaching of Hillel is the negative version of the Golden Rule; it says what we should refrain from doing instead of what we should do.
By contrast, Jesus wants his followers to be the kind of people who actively treat others well, and not for selfish reasons. He states this first in a general but suitably striking way before getting down to cases. “Love your enemies,” he says, catching the attention of everyone who was there to truly listen. Note that just as we should understand the commandment to love as being exemplified in doing good to our enemies, blessing and praying for them, so too should we understand “enemies” as those who hate, curse, and mistreat us—whether or not we hate them in turn.
That’s important in the context of the story we have in Luke thus far. Clearly, Jesus has already made enemies in the scribes, Pharisees, and even the Herodians, and it’s not unreasonable to think that this was public knowledge. Jesus doesn’t hate them, but they hate him. And as someone being treated so unfairly himself, how should Jesus respond? What example would he set for his followers? We know the answer, but they will have to wait a little while longer to see the ultimate demonstration of love for one’s enemies in the crucifixion.
Then Jesus gives more concrete examples. Not surprisingly, given what Jesus has already said, most of the examples have to do with being mistreated: being slapped in anger, or having things taken from you. How should the followers of Jesus respond? Humbly turn the other cheek; don’t try to keep people from taking more or try to get what was taken back.
If the command to love one’s enemies was startling enough, these examples may seem even more so. Wait, what are you saying, Jesus? Are you saying we should just let people smack us around whenever they’d like? Are we supposed to let others help themselves to everything we own and just stand back and smile?
No. These sayings aren’t meant to be turned into moral laws; they’re meant to illustrate the more general principle of acting in love toward those who do us wrong. Note too that there may be an element of class distinction here, for not everyone listening to Jesus had things worth taking. Giving to those who ask and not trying to recover stolen property are ways for the rich to have compassion toward the poor.
All of this culminates in the Golden Rule. How would we want others to treat us, especially if they thought we had done them wrong? That’s the kind of people we ourselves should be, whatever others do. And as we’ll see, our motivation for doing so is because we want to be like our Father in heaven.

